KANT'S FORMALISM (diagram) -- by Gordon Ziniewicz
Key Alternatives:
| heteronomy | autonomy |
| interest | disinterest |
| inclination | duty |
| acting because of interest | acting out of duty |
| outward act of overt action | inward act of decision |
| willing not in accord with universal moral law | willing in accord with universal moral law |
|
INTENTION Intentionalism: What counts is the motive or reason for acting. Only intentions are good or bad: One's heart is "in the right place" or "in the wrong place" |
ACT Formalism: What counts is the act in itself; one must determine whether acts are right or wrong in themselves (by means of pre-existing standards [Plato], reason and law of non-contradiction [Kant], or God's will [Christianity]. Formalism is allied to universalism. |
CONSEQUENCES Consequentialism: Whether consequences are good or bad determines whether acts are right or wrong (e.g., utilitarianism). This view is often linked to teleologism, which emphasizes purposes or ends. |
CONDITIONS (or circumstances) Situationism: Acts are right or wrong in terms of actual conditions or circumstances (objectivism without universalism) |
||